BooksEpisode IEpisode IIEpisode IIIEpisode IXExpanded UniverseKathleen KennedyLive-Action TelevisionOld Republic EraPodcastsPrequel TrilogySequel TrilogyThe Force AwakensThe Last Jedi

Could the Chosen One Prophecy Be Wrong?

This Week, We Consider the Possibility That This Prophecy is a Sith Manipulation

Could the Chosen One Prophecy Be Wrong?

Could the Chosen One Prophecy Be Wrong? The mythology of Star Wars was sent into hyperspace when Qui Gon Jinn first mentioned the prophecy of the “Chosen One” in The Phantom Menace. This prophecy has recently been fully revealed in the novel Master and Apprentice. But is there more to it than meets the eye? This week, we take a closer look at this central element of the Skywalker saga.

In the 20 years since the release of Episode 1: The Phantom Menace, Star Wars fans have wondered and speculated about the infamous “Chosen One” prophecy. This prophecy has continued to appear in canon, and recently has been fully revealed in Claudia Gray’s Master and Apprentice. What is the “Chosen One Prophecy,” and could it be wrong; could it be just a part of a grand plan for the manipulation of the Jedi, constructed by the Sith themselves?

Father's Day Special

Listen on Google Podcasts!

Listen on Apple Podcasts!

(Check out last week’s episode HERE!)
What is “The Chosen One Prophecy?”

Only through sacrifice of many Jedi will the Order cleanse the sin done to the nameless. The danger of the past is not past, but sleeps in an egg. When the egg cracks, it will threaten the galaxy entire. When the Force itself sickens, past and future must split and combine. A Chosen One shall come, born of no father, and through him will ultimate balance in the Force be restored. (from Master and Apprentice by Claudia Gray)

Theory: Could the Chosen One Prophecy Be Wrong?

(Source: –

Putting all these pieces together, then, the Chosen One prophecy could well lie at the heart of Palpatine’s master plan. He didn’t just want to create, and rule, an Empire; he wanted to rule it forever. He knew he’d have to use Darth Plageuis’ power to manipulate the Midichlorians and create the perfect host. But the complicating factor is that Palpatine wouldn’t necessarily know where in the galaxy this powerful being had been born. Thus Palpatine gave the prophecy of the Chosen One to the Jedi, or perhaps even fabricated it altogether. He knew that, as the Jedi Order grew, the Jedi would organize themselves so that any Force-sensitives would be brought to the Temple. The Jedi would serve his goal, bringing his creation to Coruscant for training, and when they encountered this Force-born child they’d naturally make him a priority.

If this theory is true, then Palpatine’s millennia-long plan moved to its endgame nine years before Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace, when he manipulated the Midichlorians and created the Chosen One. Presumably at this point in time he’d already positioned himself so that, should the child be brought to the Temple, he’d be able to subtly exert an influence; tie-in books have recently confirmed that, as a Senator, Palpatine had excellent connections with the Jedi. But here is where Darth Sidious’ plan almost went wrong, because Anakin Skywalker was born on Tatooine, a Rim world outside the Republic. The Jedi never discovered him as an infant at all.

Fortunately for Palpatine, the dark side of the Force was ascendant, and as a result events began to conspire against the Jedi. Qui-Gon Jinn – one of the few Jedi to have really studied the prophecies – stumbled upon the 9-year-old Anakin Skywalker on Tatooine, and brought him to the Temple. Palpatine must have been delighted; because Anakin hadn’t been trained as a Jedi from an early age, he was that much easier to manipulate. Darth Sidious’ plans were back on track for the next few years, until the moment when Anakin’s body was so badly injured on Mustafar, and he ceased to be a viable host. That was when things all fell apart, and ever since then he’s been trying to recover.

Hot Takes!

The English translation of the Japanese title of The Rise of Skywalker has fans wondering if there’s a future to the Skywalkers. Meanwhile, another star of the film talks of being emotionally overwhelmed by the story. And Lucasfilm has taken JJ Abram’s protege and put her in full control of a galaxy far, far away. It’s time for Hot Takes!

  1. Star Wars: Rise of Skywalker Gets a Different Title in Japan
    (Source: ComicBook Review –
    According to the fan Twitter account Star Wars Stuff, the film’s Japanese theatrical title is Star Wars: Dawn of Skywalker, suggesting a new beginning of sorts for the Skywalker family in the eagerly anticipated film.
  2. Keri Russell says Abrams’ new Star Wars script made her cry
    (Source: –
    Keri Russell says that when J.J. Abrams sent her his version of the script for Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, it overwhelmed her. “When I read his script that he wrote I cried,” she told The Associated Press in a recent interview. “I mean who knows what it will turn out to be and I hope it remains true to what he originally wanted.” With similar statements having been made by Billie Lourd, Oscar Isaac, and Richard E. Grant, is this signs of good things to come, or just more pre-release hyperbole?
  3. The Rise of Skywalker Co-Producer, Michelle Rejwan Hired As Lucasfilm’s Senior Vice President of Live Action Development and Production
    (Source: Variety Magazine –
    Kathleen Kennedy said that Rejwan would be responsible for “shaping the future in all areas of story development, from theatrical film development to live action content for Disney Plus. Kennedy also said that… “Working with Michelle over the last seven years as a producer on both The Force Awakens and now The Rise of Skywalker, I have seen first-hand her skills collaborating with writers and directors, and I’ve been incredibly impressed with her creative skills and her ability to manage the complexity surrounding these massive projects. I know the importance of building a team that you trust and have fun working with – it is paramount to our success.” -Rejwan’s resume is definitely impressive including work on Star Trek: Into Darkness and Super 8. Now that this decision has been announced, what do you think this means for future productions in a galaxy far, far away?


  • 00:00:00 – Making Star Wars Network
  • 00:00:40 – Introduction/Banter
  • 00:15:40 – Hot Takes!
  • 00:35:34 – Could the Chosen One Prophecy Be Wrong?
  • 01:05:16 – Anything Else?
  • 01:10:41 – Lucasfilm Disclaimer

Check out our website:

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel:

Check out our Patreon page:

Follow us on Twitter:

Like us on Facebook:

Check out our Instagram:


You May Also Like

Tatooine Sons

Join us as David (The Bow Tie Jedi Guy) passes on a legacy of Star Wars passion to his two sons, Samuel the Hutt, and BB-N8! If you've ever sat around with your kids talking about Obi Wan Kenobi, Luke Skywalker, Jar Jar Binks, The Clone Wars and Star Wars Rebels, or anything from the Star Wars universe, this is the podcast for you! New episodes weekly.
Back to top button